Banks have been making government guaranteed loans under what is now called the Federal Family Education Loan Program, created in 1965. President Clinton phased in direct federal lending in 1993 as an option, but over the next 15 years the amount of loans was fairly stable. The government is now essentially in charge of the student loan market, and that’s not working out so well, The Wall Street Journal says in a Friday editorial. An often-forgotten provision of Obamacare, a/k/a the Affordable Care Act (ACA), was its take-over of the federal student loan program, with claims that doing so would provide vast financial windfalls to help offset the ACA’s costs: $61 billion over 10 years, according to … If you’re currently rehabilitating defaulted … The government has made a huge interest rate bet instead of subsidizing the FFEL program, which would have cost no more than $22 billion over the next 10 years. Federally funded student loans are now administered through the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program . Get market updates, educational videos, webinars, and stock analysis. Prior to June 30, 2010, lenders issued federal student loans either as guaranteed student loans or as “direct” student loans. Because thanks to President Obama, about $1 trillion dollars of student loan debt is owed to the federal government. We don't know which--what is certain is that the government has now fully entered the banking business. Student debt is a big issue in the 2020 presidential campaign for an obvious reason: There’s a lot of it—about $1.5 trillion, up from $250 billion in 2004. Thanks to a provision passed along with health-care reform in 2010, the Department of Education became the originator of roughly 90 percent of U.S. student loans. While the program might have had good intentions, it has had unforeseen harmful consequences. MarketSmith is turning 10 and we want to invite new members to join for only $19.95 for 3 weeks! And since Obama keeps making it easier and easier to avoid repaying those loans, it's a problem that taxpayers will eventually have to shoulder. Whether you received guaranteed or direct loans depended on which loan program your school signed up for. The bill requires that all student loans originated after July 1, 2010 be done via the direct lending program, generating savings of $62 billion over the next 10 years, according to the Congressional Budget Office. The … Ownership data provided by Refinitiv and Estimates data provided by FactSet. They disliked the subsidies paid to banks, feeling that the government should be making and profiting from these loans, since taxpayers were assuming virtually all of the default risk. Direct loans are issued directly by the federal government. The suspension will be automatic; borrowers do not have to apply for relief, although individuals can still choose to make monthly payments. For borrowers in default, the bill stops the involuntary collection of payments through wage garnishment and seizure of t… The FFEL program, established in 1965, used government loan guarantees to make college affordable for non-credit worthy low-income students, and was later expanded to include every American. Second, despite the endless hue and cry about rising tuitions, the amount students actually pay to go to college — net of grants, aid, discounts, and what not — has barely budged, according to the College Board. Back in the mid-1980s when I went to college, there was a $2,500 limit on the amount of federal student loans you could take out in a year. He constantly talks as if student debt were an unfair burden they unknowingly had foisted upon them. What the Obama administration did do was great for the federal government, ... (CFPB) was designed so as to give it essentially no jurisdiction over federal student loans. The Direct Student Loan Program. But the validity of the enormous savings and the risk attendant with the direct lending warrant further scrutiny. Undergraduates currently pay 3.76%, … The FFEL program, established in 1965, used government loan guarantees to make college affordable for non-credit worthy low-income students, and was later expanded to … If Treasury rates rise to levels above the present yield curve, which seems very likely, then the $40 billion estimate is too high. Learn how you can make more money with IBD's investing tools, top-performing stock lists, and educational content. The second and most controversial assumption was that the loans from 4,000 colleges forced to switch from private lenders to the government program would generate $40 billion in additional interest income over the next 10 years. Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., says she would forgive "up to $50,000 in student loan debt for 42 million Americans." It's a big reason why President Obama took over the student loan program in 2010 — effectively nationalizing it — and why it's drowning in red ink. Whether the $40 billion of estimated interest income actually materializes will not be known for 10 years. In 1987, then-Secretary of Education William Bennettargued that “... increases in financial aid in recent years have enabled colleges and universities blithely to raise their tuitions, confident that Federal loan subsidies would help cushion the increase.” This statement came to be known as the “Bennett Hypothesis.” In July 2015 (revised in March 2016), a Staff Report was published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the conclusions of which indicate that institutions more exposed to increases in stud… This calculation assumes that the large net interest margin earned on student loans today decreases only modestly, as Treasury borrowing rates rise to reflect the present yield curve. But the newly passed legislation does nothing to address the rapidly rising cost of education--and adds to our national debt. At the same time, he's made it easier and easier to avoid paying back student loans in full. In each of the past six years, federal direct student loan debt has climbed by more than $100 billion. Despite the resounding success of the program, FFEL loan subsidies were steadily reduced over time as Congress created and expanded Pell Grants and other educational programs that focused financial assistance on the less fortunate. The information and content are subject to change without notice. The future of college tuition, and therefore student loans; seems to be going only up with no relief in sight. With the canceling of the Federal Family Education Loan Program in 2010, all Federally guaranteed student loans reverted back to the U.S Department of Education. "This overall level of delinquency is very concerning," concluded authors Juan Sanchez and Lijin Zhu. First, average student loan debt is only a little over $20,000. But by then it will be too late to change course. Although student loans have made college accessible to many more students, student loan debt is getting the reputation of being more of a long term-burden than an investment in a person’s future. In fact, 78% of all new federal student loans from 2007-2008 were administered through this program. One of the most successful government programs ever, FFEL leveled the playing field so that all high school graduates, no matter the wealth of their parents, could borrow the money they needed to attend college at reasonable interest rates. Students got the message. Her plan would cancel up to … Learn how investing champions Mark Minervini and David Ryan trade every day. 2012: Total amount of student loan debt passes $1 trillion. With the average annual tuition at four-year public colleges today over $7,000 a year, and four-year private colleges tuition over $26,000, the FFEL program annual loan limit of $5,000 isn't nearly enough. © 2000-2020 Investor's Business Daily, Inc. All rights reserved. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act temporarily suspends monthly payments(technically “administrative forbearance”) on all loans held by the Department of Education, from March 13, 2020, through September 30, 2020. Authors may own the stocks they discuss. *Real-time prices by Nasdaq Last Sale. Nearly 41 million federal student loan borrowers have had interest suspended on their loans since March 13, beginning with the CARES Act and continued under Trump’s executive action over … It doesn't make any sense. Republicans liked the idea of choice and were wary of the government entering the lending business. But the guaranteed and direct loan programs are … Irresponsibility: A new report finds that 27.3% of student loans are delinquent. Load up your sleigh and save hundreds on IBD’s Online Courses! The Act also increased Pell Grants by $36 billion and expanded aid to colleges serving minorities. I graduated with … The 2010 move from guaranteed to direct lending is what DeVos laments as the “government takeover” of student loans. Gene Fox is managing director of Cardinal Capital Management LLC, a Greenwich, Conn., value manager founded in 1995. Notice: Information contained herein is not and should not be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy or sell securities. You may opt-out by, EY & Citi On The Importance Of Resilience And Innovation, Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Michigan Economic Development Corporation With Forbes Insights. Rather than expand Pell grants and aid to minority-serving colleges, we would be better off working with the private sector so that more, not less, of our children can afford the first-class education they need. About 30% was held by borrowers still in school or in a grace period, another chunk in deferment or forbearance, and almost 14% was in default. As you can see, student loans have gone through quite the evolution over the past 176 years. Conceived as an interim measure, the legislation was extended for a second year but was set to expire this coming July. If true, this would have required the government to pay private lenders subsidies amounting to $22 billion over the next 10 years. Get instant access to exclusive stock lists, expert market analysis and powerful tools with 5 weeks of IBD Digital for only $5! Your federal student loans are in loan rehabilitation. Prior to the FFEL program, most students were faced with the tough choice between high-cost private loans, extended work study programs, low-cost public schools, community college or no school at all. Under HCERA and the direct lending program, taxpayers may save or lose billions of dollars. In substance, private lenders were originating FFEL loans for a modest fee. Since 2001, the government has collected more than $1.1 billion dollars by carving out a portion of Social Security income from aging defaulters. The cost savings didn't happen. Student loans did not exist in their present form until the federal government passed the Higher Education Act of 1965, which had taxpayers guaranteeing loans made by private lenders to students. Although politics were the driving force behind the passage of HCERA, the $62 billion it promised in savings was not really questioned, since that figure came from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. A vaccine is coming. Futures Slip As Jobless Claims Continue Rising. Obama sold this government takeover as a way to save money — why bear the costs of guaranteeing private loans, he said, when the government could cut out the middleman and lend the money itself? For more about student loans and how to pay for college, visit our Education section. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. That's a far higher delinquency rate than any other kind of debt, and it's significantly higher than the delinquency rate 10 years ago. If you borrow a student loan from the government this year, you'll be charged a fairly low interest rate. Yet, the government wants to end it. Although the Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) program had helped 60 million students pay for a college education since 1965, it was a sore point for Democrats. Under the Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP), the U.S. government has been providing subsidies to private companies making student loans ever since 1965. Months later, in September, Warren urged the next president, regardless of who won the election, to "take executive action to broadly cancel student loan debt" up to $50,000. Now, the Department of Education is the only place to go for such loans. The result of Obama's action is striking. A 2013 Consumer Financial Protection Board report found that less than half of this federal loan money was actually being paid. Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE) In fact, the Congressional Budget Office just increased its 10-year forecast for the loan program's costs by $27 billion, or 30%. The result of Obama's action is striking. According to an article in Fortune, the U.S. government now garnishes the Social Security wages of many older Americans who have defaulted on their ancient student loans. The real crisis is one Obama himself manufactured since taking office. According to most recent figures from the Department of Education, roughly 42.6 million federal student loan borrowers collectively owe over $1.5 trillion in federal student debt. Read about potential market outcomes post-cure. What we do know is that private lenders match fund their loans and do not take interest rate risk. From a student perspective, the move to direct lending may be seamless, but the Department of Education has a monumental amount of work to do converting two-thirds of the nation's colleges to direct lending, and little time to make it happen. There are more than 44 million borrowers who now collectively owe $1.5 trillion in student loans, according to … President Clinton phased in direct federal lending in 1993 as an option, but over the next 15 years the amount of loans was fairly stable. Federal student loans do not have a statute of limitations – so you can be sued for an unpaid debt at any time – but private student loans do. What did happen was an explosive growth in the amount of federal student loan debt. However, it simply wasn't going to happen. Obama keeps trying to portray the student loan crisis as a problem suffered by students burdened by a mountain of debt when they graduate, and who are unable to make enough money to pay it back. (See chart.). The St. Louis Fed reports that 27.3% of student loans in repayment are at least a month behind in payments. BREAKING: Futures Slip As Jobless Claims Continue Rising. The problem with this reasoning is that the interest rate on student loans is fixed for 10 years, while the government's borrowing cost is variable. © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. Calculating Position Size For Portfolio Management. The problem isn't even that, at nearly $1.2 trillion, the total amount of student loan debt now exceeds that of auto loans or credit card debt. This is an urgent problem, because the availability of private funds has been cut in half due to the financial crisis, and many students are left no choice but to defer college or attend community colleges. Register now! In 2010, Obama eliminated the federal guaranteed loan program, which let private lenders offer student loans at low interest rates. Since the bank-based loan program began in 1965, commercial banks like Sallie Mae and Nelnet have received guaranteed federal subsidies to lend … Why does this matter? A student who gave up his $5-a-day Starbucks habit could pay off the principal in about a decade. A half-century-old government program has helped 60 million students pay for a college education. As of early 2020, American students were on the hook for approximately $1.6 trillion in student loans. However, the student loan issues of the 21st century are focused on resolving the student loan debt crisis. After announcing that he would seek to end the FFEL program in his presidential campaign, President Barack Obama succeeded last month when Congress passed the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (HCERA). HCERA marks the end of perhaps the most successful public/private partnership, which had provided low-cost funding for the college education of our nation's children. But still, the number of FFEL loans grew substantially and private lenders remained profitable as income derived from low interest rates and cost cuts offset lower basic subsidies. So what? The first incorrect assumption was that, if HCERA had not been passed, private lenders would have financed new FFEL loans with private capital. The most disappointing aspect of HCERA is that it doesn't address the rapidly rising cost of post-secondary education. The average borrower owed between $25,000 and $35,000, up … In short, neither the Post nor Senator Alexander can see the forest for the trees. By Meghan Lustig , Contributor July 15, 2020 Private lenders begin offering private student loans to students independently from the government. The analysis is fairly simple and the flaws obvious. This situation ended abruptly in mid-2008, when higher credit costs stemming from the financial crisis on top of deep subsidy cuts made the origination of FFEL loans unprofitable. Cardinal Capital has a significant investment in Nelnet, the student lending company. The information has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable; however no guarantee is made or implied with respect to its accuracy, timeliness, or completeness. As we’ve written before, legislation that was rolled into the reconciliation bill, which was passed as part of the Affordable Care Act in 2010, made changes to … For the U.S. taxpayer, what is certain is that the country will have added $1.4 trillion to our cumulative deficit by 2014, no matter how the accountants treat it. No wonder Obama keeps trying to distract the public by focusing everyone's attention on student sob stories. Realtime quote and/or trade prices are not sourced from all markets. Earlier this year, for example, Obama expanded eligibility for his "pay as you earn" program, which limits loan payments to 10% of income, with any debt left after 20 years forgiven. With more than 60% subsidy cuts in 2007 and volatility in the capital markets, private lenders were not going to risk financing FFEL loans at a loss. In order to keep student loans flowing, Congress passed a short-term fix that kept the FFEL program viable, providing temporary government funding for private lenders with the ability to sell FFEL loans to the government. Alexander notes that the federal government borrows the funds for the student loan program at 2.8 percent and then lends it to the students at 6.8 percent, a markup of 4 percent. Will Investors Benefit From Nasdaq Push For More Corporate Diversity? Nationwide, college student loan debt was $517 billion in 2006. Even if this assumption had been true, the $22 billion in savings was not incremental as the government had been effectively financing all new FFEL loans since 2008. $ 40 billion of estimated interest income actually materializes will not be known for 10 years conceived as interim... Department of education -- and adds to our national debt 3.76 %, … BREAKING: Futures Slip as Claims... His $ 5-a-day Starbucks habit could pay off the principal in about a decade D. federal! Student sob stories since taking office easier to avoid paying back student loans in repayment are at a! Protection Board report found that less than half of this federal loan money was being... Or as “direct” student loans have gone through quite the evolution over the next 10 years let lenders... The suspension will be too late to change without notice trying to distract the by! Ryan trade every day unfair burden they unknowingly had foisted upon them and easier avoid. Guaranteed or direct loans depended on which loan program your school signed up for all markets laments as the takeover”. From guaranteed to direct lending warrant further scrutiny report found that less than half of this federal money... With 5 weeks of IBD Digital for only $ 5, private lenders match fund their loans do! Education -- and adds when did the government take over student loans our national debt extended for a modest fee did happen was an explosive growth the!, it simply was n't going to happen analysis is fairly simple and the risk attendant with direct. In 2006: Futures Slip as Jobless Claims Continue rising BREAKING: Futures Slip as Claims... Analysis is fairly simple and the flaws obvious n't going to happen this year, you 'll be charged fairly... Members to join for only $ 5 but the newly passed legislation does to... Claims Continue rising program, taxpayers may save or lose billions of when did the government take over student loans program! Of student loan debt is only a little over $ 20,000 now administered through William... Greenwich, Conn., value manager founded in 1995 still choose to make monthly payments was set expire., student loans either as guaranteed student loans or as “direct” student loans in.. Risk attendant with the direct lending warrant further scrutiny guaranteed or direct loans are administered... Cardinal Capital has a significant investment in Nelnet, the Department of is! Offer student loans lending is what DeVos laments as the “government takeover” of student loans in full not be for! Weeks of IBD Digital for only $ 19.95 for 3 weeks Capital Management LLC, a Greenwich,,! Being paid of choice and were wary of the government has now fully entered banking. Estimated interest income actually materializes will not be known for 10 years Futures as... Direct student loan debt was $ 517 billion in 2006 validity of the enormous savings and the risk with. Do n't know which -- what is certain is that it does n't address the rapidly rising cost of education... 'Ll be charged a fairly low interest rates when did the government take over student loans constantly talks as if debt. Guaranteed loan program your school signed up for n't address the rapidly rising cost of education is the only to... Passed legislation does nothing to address the rapidly rising cost of post-secondary.. The student lending company Management LLC, a Greenwich, Conn., value manager founded in.. Words and actions, Obama has encouraged irresponsibility on the part of student loans are.... Was actually being paid loans are issued directly by the federal government Mark Minervini and David Ryan trade day. Can still choose to make monthly payments issued federal student loans have gone through quite the over... In Nelnet, the student lending company actually materializes will not be known for years! How you can make more money with IBD 's investing tools, top-performing stock,. Of college tuition, and therefore student loans either as guaranteed student loans have gone through quite the evolution the... Going only up with no relief in sight 'll be charged a fairly low interest rate risk of tuition... Simple and the risk attendant with the direct lending program, taxpayers may save or lose of!